Check Out This Post!

Harmon Killebrew On David Letterman!?

With the appearance of Joe Mauer last week on Jimmy Fallon, I was reminded of another episode of a famous Twin who appeared on late ni...

Showing posts with label Metropolitan Stadium. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Metropolitan Stadium. Show all posts

Monday, December 7, 2015

A Brush With Twins Fame - Rod Carew




The piece below, contributed by my long-time friend and Twins fanatic Greg Aase, is useful in answering a number of questions, especially "What was it like as a young fan to experience a Rod Carew autograph signing while he was in his prime?" Was he more like a Michael Cuddyer or Pat Neshek (very personable) or a Danny Valencia (actually cussed-out a youth in spring training after multiple autograph requests)? Or was he something in-between those extremes? 
It also offers interesting insights into player access in the late 1970s, and how making a very simple request could place even a young kid in the presence of a Twins legend. Very fitting, coming from a fellow born on the eve of the very first Twins World Series game, on Oct. 5, 1965!

Late afternoon, July 19thJuly 19, 1976.  A warm summer evening.  I am ten years old and on a school bus with my father.  Along with 40 other fathers and sons, we are traveling north on the various state highways and county roads between the small farm town of New Prague and our destination - Metropolitan Stadium in Bloomington, MN, aka the Met, home of the Minnesota Twins.  The local Rotary club held an annual father/son trip to The Met for its members, and this year we were going to watch our boys take on the Tigers.
To this 10 year old, a trip to the Met, or any other trip to the “Cities” (as most out state Minnesotans call Minneapolis/St. Paul), was a big deal.  Although New Prague was 39 miles from the stadium, there weren’t too many reasons for my family to leave our small town.  The general train of thought was that if you couldn’t find what you were looking for at Don’s Red Owl (the local grocery store), Rynda’s Hardware Hank (the really old time hardware store, complete with massive wooden cabinets of screws and toggles), Anthony’s (the god-awful clothing store, which offered the complete line of stiff, scratchy Dickies jeans), McMahon’s Snyder Drug (with their modest selection of DC Comics), or the local Ben Franklin (which was my main supplier of Topps Baseball Cards) you probably didn’t need it. So to head north, to the big city, was a big deal.
This 10 ten year old also loved the Met.  Having seen no other major league baseball stadium in person, I had no idea that the Met was, essentially, a minor league ballpark on steroids (see post "Met Stadium Pictorial, 1955-1961," Aug., 2011).  I didn’t know the history behind the place.  Officially built by the Minneapolis power brokers for the two minor league ball parks in the late 1950’s, it was really bait to attract major league teams to what the powers that be thought was now a major league town.  It was quickly, and haphazardly, expanded multiple times when the Twins and the Vikings came to town in the early 1960’s.  By the time I made my first trip to the Met in 1975, I had no idea the general consensus was it was a poorly maintained stadium with a whole bunch of lousy seats in the upper deck in left field, no upper deck in right, and a bunch of high school style bleacher seats everywhere else.   I also didn’t know that the Vikings, and to a much lesser degree, the Twins, were seeking a newer, shinier home (photo: 10 year-old Greg Aase, resplendent in brown corduroy).
I didn’t care about any of that. I loved the different brightly colored tiled panels on the outside walls. The parking lot seemed endless.  I loved the huge scoreboard with the Longines’ “Official Watch” at the top. I loved how you could sit almost anywhere, and in 1976, there were plenty of open seats, and watch the Northwest and North Central jets seemingly fly right next to the stadium as they came in to land at the “international” airport.  I enjoyed looking out past the outfield and the scoreboard and see the still open fields of south Bloomington and the Minnesota River valley.  It was a like a whole different world to me, a long ways away from New Prague, and that was fine with me.



Even though I didn’t know it then, the trip had some personal meaning.  My father and I were not particularly close in 1976.  He was a math and science teacher at New Prague High School and a very smart man.  Growing up, he was an Eagle Scout and a lifeguard. Although he taught math, his true calling was auto mechanics.  Taught by his father to wrench, he could diagnose and fix any car placed in front of him.  His nights and weekends were spent out in his garage, either fixing other cars to make extra cash, or tinkering on one of his own cars  (above photo: Ron Aase).
His only son couldn’t be less in his father’s image.  I bombed out of Cub Scouts, much to the disappointment of Scoutmaster Aase, thanks to my incompetence with knots and my disinterest in camping. I greatly preferred reading over math.  Multiple attempts by him to teach me to swim were unsuccessful and usually ended in shouting and tears.  I had no clue how an internal combustion engine worked and generally didn’t care. I loved the Beatles.  Dad’s taste in music was whatever WCCO-AM played, because that was the only station he ever listened to.  
One of our only common points was baseball.  The soundtrack to our summer hours in the car, or my fruitless time helping him fix cars in his garage, was to the smooth tones of Herb Carneal.  When things between us grew silent, we could talk about the sad decline of Tony Oliva, the Twins’ acute lack of pitching, or how cheap Calvin Griffith was getting.   A game of catch in the backyard, or attempts at the school ballfield down the street to fix my batting stance, were times that Dad and I had together that seem to bring some degree of peace to both of us.  So I looked forward to this father/son trip.
Not surprisingly, Dad and I had different plans for this particular trip.  After arriving at the Met, I purchased a 1976 yearbook and obtained a pen from my father. I had determined that this year was the year I was getting Rod Carew’s autograph (photo below: Rod Carew, via Sports Illustrated - August 19, 1976).


There was only one guy I cared about in 1976, and that was Rodney Cline Carew.  Four time batting champ, nine time All Star, the purest hitter in baseball at that time, and, best of all, a lefty like me.  He was the only superstar the Twins had.  One of my prized possessions was his 1975 Topps card, and when I attempted to play baseball at the afternoon Recreation games at Memorial Park I tried, to the mock and ridicule of my peers, to copy his stance. Just how I was going to get is autograph, I had no clue.  But I wanted it.
After we passed the ticket gate, I told Dad I was going to wander the stadium and see if I could get Carew’s autograph.  He told me not to leave.  I didn’t understand why.  Unbeknownst to me, one of Dad’s fellow math teachers, Don Dvorak, grew up in Waseca and went to Mankato State University with Jerry Terrell. Terrell was, at that time, a utility infielder for the Twins.  Dvorak was still
friendly with Jerry and had contacted him to see if he could visit with him before the game. At some point, my father had gotten me attached to this visit.   So, instead of wandering off on my own, my father told me to go with Mr. Dvorak.  From the bowels of the lower deck of the Met, we walked straight to the end of the aisle next to the Twins dugout.
Professional baseball in 1976 was a different world than the corporate, limited controlled access, state that we live in today.  In 1976, it wasn’t a big deal to walk down to the dugout, tell the bored security guard that you are here to see Jerry Terrell, give the guard your name, wait for the guard to yell at Jerry in the dugout to say that somebody was there to see him, and have Jerry yell back to “let them in”.  And that was pretty much how it happened.    One minute I’m standing at end of the aisle next the dugout, and the next minute I’m in the Twins dugout, shaking Jerry Terrell’s hand (above photo: Carew makes bubblegum cast of Terrell for posterity).
Jerry introduced us to a few other players sitting around the dugout.  The first was Craig Kusick
(“Mongo”), a kid from Wisconsin who should have been the power hitting first baseman the Twins desperately needed and got a few years later when they found a Bloomington kid named Hrbek, and Vic Albury, a journeyman pitcher. Vic looked like an extra from the Godfather via the sales department of Wally McCarthy’s Lindahl Olds – a thin mustache, short dark hair parted on one side and slicked down, a jaunty look on his face and a heater in his hand.  When Jerry called him over, Vic got up from the bench, walked over to where Terrell, Kusick, Mr. Dvorak and I were standing, gave me a skeptical, bored look, shook my hand, asked me how I was doing, and waited for me to stammer back “fine”.  He must have then determined that he had fulfilled his obligation, because he then nodded, turned, went back to his spot on the bench, took a long drag on his cigarette and pretended like all of us, including Terrell and Kusick, didn’t exist (photo above: Craig Kusick card via "When Topps Had Balls" Blogspot / below: Vic Albury, in a mellow, reflective mood)

Albury: "So...who let the snot kids in?"

Even though all this was great I wanted something more.  Vic and Craig and Jerry were all nice, but they were the B team.   I wanted Carew.  Unfortunately, Rod was nowhere to be found.  After a few minutes of chit chat, I couldn’t stand it anymore - I finally had to ask Jerry were Rod was.
His response - “He’s down in the clubhouse - he took his swings early.”
That was terrible.  Jerry was, in my mind, the step to get to Carew.  I mean, it was awesome to be in the Twins dugout, hanging with the players, but Carew was The Man.  And my quest to get his autograph was going to end in failure.
Then Jerry gave me hope.
“If he comes out at all before the game, he usually signs over there”, pointing to the end of the aisle just down from the dugout.  
After thanking Jerry and Craig, we were escorted out and up into the stands.  Mr. Dvorak headed back to where the rest of the group was sitting. I walked over to the next aisle and waited, with  5 other kids, for Carew.
Although access to players was much better in 1976 than it is now, Carew was the exception.  Rodney back in those days was considered “difficult”.  There is a former Minneapolis Tribune sportswriter that hates Carew to this day. Some of the grizzled sportswriter veterans that are still around will occasionally pass along a story on how prickly Carew could be.  He also never, ever signed autographs.
I stood at the end of the aisle for 15 minutes, and game time was approaching.  I can’t guarantee what the other 5 boys were thinking, but I suspect it was the same thing that was passing through my mind - we were going to strike out.  But then, running out of the dugout, and running over to the end of the aisle, was #29.  





He didn’t make eye contact with any of us, he just took whatever we put in front of him - a baseball, a piece of paper, a 1976 yearbook with his face on the cover, and he signed.  A big flourish of a signature, actually legible.  He signed everything put in front of him, and then he was gone without a word.  The whole thing might have taken 2 minutes.  But on his page in my yearbook - his autograph.






Thanks to the Internet, I now know the Twins won that night, 6 to 5.  Reliever Bill Campbell got the win.  Carew got a hit.  Jerry Terrell even got in the game.  It was a meaningless game to a 1976 season where the Twins were out of it by the All-Star break.  To be truthful, I don’t remember any of that. What does matter are the things I carry today - the great time that an awkward 10 year old kid spent with his father, the kindness  that a then-complete stranger showed me, a perfect summer evening at a long gone outdoor stadium, and two minutes with one of my boyhood heroes.  

So long everybody! - Herb Carneal

Saturday, December 5, 2015

Facebook: Metropolitan Stadium 1956



Field of Dreams...old photo of Met Stadium when it opened.
Posted by E Kelly Keady on Thursday, December 3, 2015

Sunday, January 19, 2014

A Winter Mind's Meandering Towards Spring

Sometime after John Elway and the Super Bowl-bound Bronco's 26-16 dismantling of the New England Patriots, this disjointed piece of reality began to unfold in my brain...Minnesota winters can be truly debilitating, I will maintain.

Behold: the scene from old Metropolitan Stadium's right field bleachers, overlooking the new right field foul territory seating. It's from the July, 1962 cover of the Twins scorecard magazine. Oh, yes - my added effects, in case you were wondering. I think it's delirium.


With Twins Fest 2014 now 5 days away, the REAL trudge towards spring and Twins baseball begins in earnest. That means, at the moment, we're at 77 days, and 19+ hours to the first game at Target Field. Ohhhh, doctor....!

Hope you're doing better waiting than I am, presently. As the old broadcasting professional put it:
"So long, everybody!" - Herb Carneal


Friday, January 17, 2014

Social Media: The Old Met In Ruin


Actual Embedded link below - 
 As he finished in the radio booth so many times, I repeat:

"So long, everybody!" (Herb Carneal)

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

This Week In Twins History : Calvin Griffith Backs Down On Moving Senators, Sept. 8, 1958

The forces keeping the Washington Senators in the nation's capitol, and away from Minneapolis, were strong and entrenched. For starters, the franchise had been a charter member of the American League since 1901, with not just a history of losing permeating the air, but also the warm, fuzzy, albeit faded memories of pennants, World Series winners, and beloved players.

 Calvin Griffith's August 27, 1958 assertion that he'd move the Nats ("Senators") to the Minneapolis/St. Paul area if an acceptable offer was made had prompted President Dwight D. Eisenhower (see below photo) to suggest that Griffith should improve the team and stay in Washington. Then, the pressure on Griffith to stay put was ratcheted up with the inevitable lawsuit. This link to the Google Docs PDF file (AND in the "sneak peak" below) maps out a fraction of the political intrigue swirling at the time, on September 8,1958.

The gist of this page:
  • In a special meeting of American League owners in Chicago, ILWashington owner Calvin Griffith succumbed to pressure ( translation: he backpedaled like a hen avoiding a fox*) from other AL owners and advised Minneapolis, MN officials that he was staying in Washington, DC. Eventual Baseball Hall Of Fame historian Joe Reichler also wrote about this development in this news piece in the Sept. 8, 1958 edition of the Ocala Star-Banner. It was a near-reversal of his oft-repeated desire to move the franchise, without completely closing the door to the possibility.

  • * Yes,I really DID need to turn Cal's Hall Of Fame stepfather Clark Griffith's nickname inside out for the sake of irony!

Griffith and AL Prez Will Harridge

Forcing the A.L. owners hand against Griffith was this development ("Sporting News" pdf) that had the Nationals ("Senators") club stockholders suing Cal once bonding was approved to enlarge Metropolitan Stadium, and that on the heels of Calvin so un-diplomatically declaring his desire to pull up stakes - it would have been uncharacteristic for him to adopt a cagey, strategic MO in any event! 

Add to this the interesting subtext that included Midway Stadium in St. Paul [cue St. Paulites beaming with pride] as another possible Twins venue in the very same article. Intrigue! As it was, Calvin had now enraged the movers and shakers in Minneapolis with his waffling - and, essentially, EVERYONE was disenchanted with him, including the Commander-In-Chief.

 Eventually, the climate would change, the seas would part, and Griffith would garner support for moving with the momentum of developing circumstances (i.e., the "Continental League") and personalities (see  "William Shea").

That source document, if you missed it the first time? The Sporting News - September 17, 1958


December 2, 1957: from appearances, it looks as if Calvin is ticking off his choice destinations to where he might relocate the Washington Senators. Minneapolis? St. Paul?Denver...or...Wichita??..for MLB Commissioner Ford Frick...actually, he's indicating he's picking Bobby Malkmus of Wichita, in the December, 1957 Rule 5 draft.

Griffith's reasons for seeking better alternatives - poor attendance, stadium location, local support - were legitimate. No, Griffith's brashness wasn't exactly Robert Irsay stealing away with the Baltimore Colts in the middle of the night, semis and U-Hauls in tow. But, by not culturing a favorable audience among fellow owners, or not effectively maneuvering the D.C. City Fathers, he almost doomed the move to Minnesota from the start.

As the great announcer ended his post-game show, I say to you:
"So long, everybody!"  (Herb Carneal)

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Kodak Snapshots - June '63 At The Met


                      Lenny Green takes his pregame cuts

It all looks so carefree and unburdened.  A sunny, 1960’s summer day at Metropolitan Stadium in Bloomington, Minnesota. From analyzing data from blurred scoreboard images, I’ve deduced this is the game the 1963 Twins played against Chicago White Sox on June 20, 1963, albeit without complete certainty. It was not uncommon to wait days for film developing, up to and beyond a week for rolls to arrive back from a photo lab in the Twin Cities back then; thus, pictures taken in late month may not have been developed until after the first of July, in this instance.

 
                                                                           Everybody was ready for a foul ball.

Usually, close up inspection of the board helps pinpoint the exact day, time of day, year, who was on the mound – but these images have the appearance of pregame warm-ups, what with the lack of game data on the board operated by Charlie Wilcox. The visiting team name is blurry at best, but the characters suggest “CHICAGO” to my eye. Have a go at it yourself, if you wish!



           Note the unpadded expanse of outfield fence!
              Plus, there was no shade -  the  second deck
              was finally constructed during the 1965 season.

 
I said it was “carefree.” As if they lived in a big, TV sitcom world of Deputy Fifes, Dick Van Dykes and Jethro Bodines. We know better. The day of this game was almost exactly 5 months before President Kennedy's assassination. Buddhist monks were immolating themselves that summer in the streets of Saigon to protest government raids on their pagodas, in the effort to crackdown on  communist infiltrators in unstable South Vietnam. Also bedeviling them was the constant threat of Chairman Khrushchev and the Russian Bear, and...the unsettling arrival of yet another cheesy Elvis movie in theatres that fall (Fun In Acapulco). The horror!

                                                                                                Crewcuts, curls  and Twins caps! 

I look at the people and wonder about their lives. So many families, and dad’s with their kids! They came, and plunked down their hard-earned cash – nobody used credit cards then - to purchase tickets the day of the game. They paid $1.50 for those outfield bleacher seats (rich guys $3 for those lower, main mezzanine seats), when the median household income per year was $5,807. They raptly watched even the warm-ups, with only the organ fills, Bob Casey’s announcements, and the impossible fielding antics of Vic Power around first base to occupy them. That they were enriched and enjoyed a day at the ballpark without the broadcasting of pop music over the PA is enviable to me. The between-inning announcements and video board hype (hysteria) in today's  ballparks severely distract from the game's simple essence, in my humble opinion.

       Dailey had that one magical year - '63

On this game day, the fans saw Harmon Killebrew and Earl Battey hit roundtrippers. Ace Twins closer Bill Dailey relieved Jim Kaat in the sixth after the latter couldn’t get past the first five batters in the frame . Yes, the guys in the 'pen certainly had to earn their money the hard way! Dailey shut down the Sox the rest of the way, giving up only 2 hits over the next four innings, along with four strikeouts. He would come into ballgames that year riding in a convertible, to the tune of “Won’t You Come Home Bill Bailey? (Louis Armstrong, You Tube video below).” That was considered a spectacle 49 years ago.


All things considered, I wouldn't mind time-traveling back to that day, to enjoy a Schweigert hot dog and a Schmidt tall one in the cheap seats!  

         1962 game program ad


As our broadcasting buddy Herb Carneal ended his broadcasts, I say "So long everybody!"

Metropolitan Stadium Photos courtesy of Radio Sputnik (Flickr photos)

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Tony Oliva: Traveling The Rutted Road To Glory

[NOTE: try clicking on photos, get larger size]
"Oliva's got real quick hands, like Stan Musial, and he's got bat control like Willie Mays. Tony always gets a piece of the ball - like nobody I've ever seen." 
- White Sox Manager Eddie Stanky, Baseball Digest, Aug. 1966.
The National Baseball Hall Of Fame announced on Monday the voting result of its Veteran's Committee, in honoring the "Golden Era" stars of the 1947-72 period. Long-overdue recognition finally awarded Ron Santo. The former Cubs third baseman was among the greatest players of the modern era, and his choice was entirely fitting. I join the chorus of others wishing he had been elected long before he passed away just over one year ago.

Q: Who was the best hitter you ever faced?
"Tony Oliva. Because, he could hit any pitch, anywhere. He did not have a weakness." - Hall of Famer Jim "Catfish" Hunter, Baseball Digest, Aug., 1992

Pre-injury, Tony Oliva was a 
multithreat, all-round player.
He was widely regarded as
a prodigy in his first, spectacular
seasons.
As I am a long-time, ardent fan of both Jim Kaat and Tony Oliva, I had already concluded that the result would not be to my liking well before the voting took place. Understand, my initial infatuation with baseball is due, in no small part, to the fabulous Twins teams of the late 1960's, when I was a tyke. These teams had rosters filled with lyrical, alliterative names like Rich Reese, "Pepe" Tovar, Leo Cardenas, Rod Carew, Jim Perry, and, of course, the late, great, Harmon Killebrew. These names, especially when rendered over the radio by announcing great Herb Carneal (1965 All Star Game audio link), were as much a part of my childhood summers as the buzzing cicadas, Dairy Queen shops and cornfields surrounding my small town in south-central Minnesota. The drive from my home to Met Stadium in suburban Bloomington, Minnesota was a short one, maybe 35, 40 minutes. I looked forward to pregame batting practice in that erector-set of a ballpark. It used to be farmland, cornfields too. Once inside the ballpark, you'd see the expanse of green, with those Twins players looking like giants, or mythical gods to my small eyes. I marveled at Oliva taking batting practice in his prime, before knee injuries and age took their toll. He could spray the ball anywhere. The first game I can recall attending was actually a Met Stadium doubleheader against the defending champion Detroit Tigers (July 29, 1969, BBRef Box) in which Tony, The Killer and Carew each hit homers. A nice way to start as a fan, I think you'd agree...

"He was as good as any hitter of his time...Better."
- Lou Piniella, Hall Of Fame Press Release, Nov. 29, 2011


 I knew that the Hall's voting board probably realized its oversight in not selecting Santo, or Gil Hodges long ago. The "Old Timers" Committee was revamped in 2001 to help correct situations such as this. I had already digested the opinions of Aaron Gleeman from a 2005 post, in which he basically dismantles the notion of Oliva as a viable candidate from purely a statistical standpoint. A truly admirable piece of writing, and analysis - there's a reason why Aaron's baseball opinions are so respected. His conclusion: many others with stats similar to Oliva's are NOT in the Hall, and others - in his view, Dick Allen - are more deserving. When you make adjustments to Allen's length of career to approximate Olivas (total at bats, games played), as Gleeman did, you definitely get the impression that Allen was the better, more valuable player.


Sept. 1, 1969 (BBRef box), : was there ever a more perfect image of extension & balance?
Joe DiMaggio revisited! Closer to the current era, Adrian Gonzalez and Don Mattingly come to mind
as being similar, complete hitters, and also because they hit left handed.
Ahem! While not trying to place myself in the position of arguing the candidacy of Oliva over Allen, I do not find it a stretch to say that Oliva was, indeed, the better player over their first 8 seasons (which ran concurrent, starting in 1964, when they each won the Rookie of The Year Awards in their respective leagues). Oliva, at the plate, running the bases, tracking flyballs, throwing out baserunners, being a buoyant presence in the clubhouse, made the Twins a better team than did the divisive Allen for his Phillies, Cardinals, Dodgers, White Sox, the Phillies again, Athletics...am I forgetting any there? In any event, you get the point. Dick "Don't Call Me Richie" Allen was a great, albeit flawed performer. Even though he was Elizabeth Taylor* in cleats, jumping from team to team...

*or Madonna, Christina Aguilera, Jennifer Anniston, for you younger kids, on the Nocturnal All-Star Team of  Love
"...The guy I watched was Tony-O...When I got to the big leagues, people assumed that Harmon Killebrew must have been my favorite player as a kid. But I always focused on watching Tony swing the bat and hit the ball to all fields."
- former Twins first baseman Kent Hrbek, Tales From The Minnesota Twins Dugout, 2007
Scroll to the :20 second mark to see Oliva
inside-outing a pitch to left ca. 1969

Bear in mind also that this was the period of great rightfielders  like Henry Aaron, Roberto Clemente, Frank Robinson...pretty easy to get lost in the shuffle. Then add to this picture the fact that Oliva played in small market Minneapolis-St.Paul. Barry Larkin also has the same dilemma as a Hall of Fame candidate, playing his whole career in Cincinnati. Gleeman's picture is incomplete, as he apparently never saw Oliva in his prime. You can make the numbers say what you want - they do matter. But you are remiss in not weighing the opinion of people who saw and played against him. His contemporaries. That should be factored for any other eligible candidate, for that matter. Their word has to count for something. For without the anecdotal, eyewitness comments of his peers, you only get a sterile, one-dimensional, statistical view of the player. I think their comments in boldtype speak volumes.

Minneapolis Star Tribune photo: Opening Night,
Oakland vs Twins April 6, 1973

Put it this way: do you see similar comments in print about Ron Santo being "the best third baseman"? Or best hitter, baserunner, fielder, etc.? Not really. At least, not that I'm aware of...this isn't to say Santo wasn't a great player. You'll notice they were saying those things for and about Tony...and I'm merely stating that Oliva deserves a nod of respect, or consideration when people speak of the elite players of his time, though the excellence of his play is fading from the collective memory; the legion of sportswriters, scouts, and players who witnessed Oliva in his time are replaced by a new generation unfamiliar with him, and puzzled by the buzz over a fellow with "only" 220 homers and .304 lifetime average.

Check Tony's first, excellent years in the table. Pitchers in the 1960's were throwing downhill off a 15-inch high mound (10" today). That was just crazy! No wonder nobody was scoring or going yard very much! It was a notorious pitching-dominated era, as countless others have pointed out. He yet compiled a marvelous power/speed profile during a challenging period:
Ask yourself: had Tony's two second-place MVP finishes been firsts instead, what would that have done for his HOF chances? BOLDFACE numbers denote league-leading totals.
MinnPost's Steve Aschburner's take  on the "Cuban Cruncher," as Linkugel and Pappas refer to him below, makes an intriguing point. He correctly stated that Oliva bested Bill Mazeroski, Orlando Cepeda, Bruce Sutter and Jim Rice consistently (often decisively) in the voting by the Hall Of Fame committee during his initial candidacy years (1982-1996). Ironically, each has leapfrogged Tony, and have been inducted in the years since he went off the main ballot. His argument, if I may paraphrase it, appears to be "if them, why not Tony?"

Batting against the White Sox, 1971, Met Stadium
"Oliva, not [Jose] Canseco , is the greatest Cuban hitter who ever lived."
-Camilo Pascual, who scouted and signed Canseco for the Oakland Athletics, in "The New Face of Baseball: The 100-Year Rise And Triumph of Latinos."

While interesting, I find problems with Aschburner's logic: it can be used to justify a lot of bad or illogical choices. I think players like Tony, Roger Maris, Don Mattingly, and Garry Templeton were Hall of Fame talents who've been given scrutiny by voters in recent years, and who lit up their leagues for an abbreviated time. And therein is the distinction I draw. At some point, we have to pay attention to the Hall's 10 year minimum standard of high calibre play. If we are to have this hallowed museum where we profess to honor only the greats, only the people that fit the criterion, then we have to follow through. Tony and these guys don't fit in.

No, it's not what people want to hear and read. Not me. Not Steve Aschburner. Certainly not Tony; while being at his core a high-spirited, kind man, he has also expressed frustration with the voting process. He wants acknowledgement as being one of the greatest players of all time, which is natural. Who can blame him? Players tend to be less inclined to use strict HOF guidelines to gauge their worth. Again, all the quotes I'm supplying attest to his talent. He brought the goods, the numbers, the greatness...but it was for only eight years, if we are being honest with ourselves. While we could quibble over including his 1973 season to tack on another year for consideration (when he came back after recuping for most of '72), even that year is nowhere near Tony's performance of his 1964-1971 period.

1970: with daughter Anita, Fathers - Kids game at Metropolitan Stadium.
Minnie Mendoza (center) and Jim Kaat (left, head on hands) are visible.
"He was one of the best hitters I ever saw. And it was not only what he hit, but when. He always seemed to be getting big hits."
- former big leaguer/current Chicago Stinking White Sox broadcaster Ken Harrelson,
 Nov. 29, 2011 Hall of Fame Press Release (check link to Denard Span's comments, You Tube).

I'm reminded of Ted Williams quoting Whitey Ford who asked:
"You mean, Tony Oliva's not in the Hall of Fame yet?"

So, were left with this: Tony and Jim Kaat will have to wait another three years before they can come up again in rotation for the voters to consider. Perhaps Oliva will have to make peace, as will his fans, with the prospect that he will have even less backing the next time, in 2014, and will remain on the outside looking in. He'll be graceful, no doubt. And we'll do well to make do, remembering the excitement, joy, and memory of our very own, Tony-O.

As our Hall of Fame Broadcaster Herb Carneal ended his postgame, I say to you:

Calvin Griffith's comments, The Sporting News, Feb. 26, 1966